Menu Close

is butcherbox worth it? banner

Is ButcherBox Worth It?

A meat delivery service like ButcherBox that delivers 100% grass-fed beef, heritage breed pork and free range organic chicken directly to your door is one of the best ways to get high-quality meat. Even before the pandemic I used meat delivery services because I regularly eat meat but don’t have time to go to the local butcher or supermarket. I try to eat healthy and like high-quality grass fed meat and organic chicken. ButcherBox sells both and a lot more. Their meat boxes are totally customizable which includes ground beef and turkey. All the meat I’ve received has been great quality, it’s always arrived on time and at a good price. In my opinion, based on the quality, customization and price, ButcherBox is definitely worth it and a pretty good deal.

The meat boxes from ButcherBox are totally customizable. You can set up your deliveries on a set time-frame which can be adjusted at any time prior to billing. That flexibility is such a great feature because what I need changes from month to month.

I’ve tried several meat delivery services and am always very happy with ButcherBox. I really like that the animals either free range or caught wild, free of added hormones & antibiotics and humanely treated.

Looking for an honest unbiased Butcher Box Review from an actual customer and business? In this article we’ll discuss what it costs, what you get, customization, the meat and why I think ButcherBox is a good deal.

What is ButcherBox?

ButcherBox is a meat delivery service that offers high quality grass fed beef, organic free range chicken, heritage pork and salmon. Meat is delivered fresh to your door in insulated boxes you can totally customize.

All of their meat is free of antibiotics & hormones. It’s shipped on dry ice so it arrives fresh. Stick it in the freezer or defrost and cook as needed.

One of the benefits of buying meat from ButcherBox is the high quality and availability. Many grocery stores don’t carry grass fed beef and organic chicken that’s free of antibiotics & hormones. But it’s easy to get if you use ButcherBox.

All the animals ButcherBox raises are humanely treated and free of hormones and antibiotics. This is rare in the meat industry which is known to treat animals poorly and pump them full of antibiotics & hormones that are then present in the meat.

ButcherBox is a good deal because you get the best meat, good service and a great price. And the boxes are customizable so you can order what you want, when you want.

butcher box with lots of meats

ButcherBox Pros:

I’m a huge fan of ButcherBox and definitely think the service is a good deal. Is ButcherBox worth it? I think so. If you want high quality grass fed beef, organic free range chicken, heritage pork and salmon delivered to your door every month, then give ButcherBox a try.

In terms of price, it’s a good deal compared to similar services and equal cuts of meat at a butcher. It’s ore expensive than the meat you’ll find at Costco, Walmart or a Supermarket, but it’s also better quality, free of hormones & antibiotics and the animals are treated humanely. Which is especially important to me.

  • Convenience: All of the meat is delivered directly to your door in an insulated box frozen on dry ice. No more going to the store to deal with long lines and inconvenience.
  • Cost Effective: ButcherBox is a good deal. The prices are very competitive when compared to equal cuts of meat and shipping is free.
  • Taste: The taste of ButcherBox’s meat is super high quality.
  • Quality: The meat is grass fed beef, free range chicken, heritage pork and salmon. It’s basically the best quality meat you can buy.

ButcherBox Cons:

Although in my opinion ButcherBox is a great deal and definitely worth it, there are still a few cons worth considering before you order.

  • Planning: Buying meat from ButcherBox takes some planning ahead. Since you’re buying a months worth of meat at once you need to consider what you’ll be eating that month before you order.
  • Space: Buying a lot of meat all at once means you’ll need space. If you live in an apartment or don’t have a second freezer it’s hard to buy a lot of meat at one time.
  • Price: Although the price is a good deal when compared to similar cuts of meat, it’s still expensive for some. There are definitely cheaper cuts of meat out there at Supermarkets, Costco and Walmart. However those cuts are of lesser quality and usually contains hormones & antibiotics.

butcher box meats beef chicken and pork

How Much Does ButcherBox Cost?

When you sign up for ButcherBox, you select both the type of meat box you want and the delivery schedule. They offer custom boxes where you pick all the meat and curated boxes where the meat is chosen for you. Curated boxes are slightly cheaper than custom meat boxes.

The meat can be delivered in 2 weeks increments. Every 2 weeks, every 4 weeks, etc.

Meat is delivered to your door frozen and on ice in an insulated, recyclable box. Because the meat is frozen when delivered, it remains fresh.

Butcher Box has options that range in price from $146-$306. Shipping is free.

Curated Box (ButcherBox Selects the Meats for you)

  • Classic Box: $146/month, 8-11 lbs meat
  • Big Box: $269/month, 16-22 lbs meat

Custom Box (You pick the meat you want)

  • Classic Box: $169/month, 9-14 lbs meat
  • Big Box: $306/month, 18-26 lbs meat

The prices shown are starting prices because you always have the option to add extras which increase the price.

The price works out to about $5 – $7 per meat serving. This is a good deal for such high-quality meat and hard to beat at stores for the same quality.

ButcherBox Options

There are a few different meat options when you order from ButcherBox.

You can select from the following:

  • Mixed Box (Beef, Chicken, Pork)
  • Beef & Pork
  • Beef & Chicken
  • All Beef
  • Custom Box (Choose whatever meats you like)

The Curated Box is selected by ButcherBox so you can’t choose what meats you get. This is a great option for meat lovers who want a variety of cuts and aren’t picky about what types they eat. You may get beef, chicken, pork or fish. And it’s cheaper.

The Custom Box is selected by you. Whatever meat you want is placed into the box. However it’s $20 – $40 more expensive.

I get a custom box delivered every month because I don’t eat much pork or fish. My box is all beef and chicken so I’m willing to pay the extra $20.

ButcherBox frequently offers their members deals on different meats. Deals are usually cheaper and in bulk. I almost always order the deals when it’s steak or chicken and keep the meat frozen. Meats expensive so I’ll take any savings I can get.

butcherbox meats in a skillet beef chicken pork fish

What Comes In A Butcher Box?

ButcherBox has a variety of meats and cuts for you to choose from.

Choose your favorite cut of high quality grass fed beef, organic free range chicken, heritage pork, salmon, Turkey, Bison and Hot Dogs.

  • Beef: Stew Beef, Sirloin Tips, Ground Beef, Trip Tip, Burgers, Flat Iron Steaks, Beef Brisket, Bottom Round Roast, Shoulder Roast, Sirloin Cap, Eye of Round Roast, Ranch Steaks, NY Strip Steaks
  • Chicken: Whole Chicken, Boneless Skinless Breasts, Chicken Tenders, Boneless or Bone-In Chicken Thighs, Ground Chicken, Drumsticks, Chicken Wings
  • Pork: Ground Pork, Breakfast Sausage, Center Cut Pork Loin Roast, Boneless Pork Chops, Pork Sirloin Roasts, Bone in Pork Butt, Bacon, Pork Tenderloin
  • Seafood: Salmon, Salmon Burgers, Cod
  • Other: Ground Turkey, Ground Bison, Uncured Hot Dogs

Why Choose ButcherBox?

I’ve tried a few meat delivery services and really like ButcherBox. The quality is high, they have a variety of meat choices, the prices are good and I like that they treat the animals humanely.

Here’s a list of reasons why I like ButcherBox.

ButcherBox Sells High Quality Meat

ButcherBox sells humanely raised grass fed or wild caught meat that’s free of antibiotics and added hormones.

All the meat I’ve received is very high quality. Good color, texture and great taste. You can definitely taste the difference between a high quality cut of meat and something of lesser quality. The meat is tender and fresh.

Because the meat is shipped frozen in an insulated container with dry ice, it remains fresh. Simply defrost the meat and cook.

ButcherBox Is Convenient

Even before Covid I was using a meat delivery service because I just don’t have enough time to grocery shop. ButcherBox makes ordering meat so convenient. You can set up all your meat deliveries online in advance and set up a recurring schedule.

The recurring schedule is great because I follow a pretty strict diet. I know exactly how much meat I’m supposed to eat each day and with deliveries ButcherBox that schedule is easy to follow.

If I need to make changes to my delivery it’s easy to do. Simply log into your ButcherBox account and select the meats you want for the next delivery. I do everything right from my phone.

Butcherbox Sells Great Tasting Meat

The way the meat tastes is a reflection of its quality. And ButcherBox sells very high quality meat. You can definitely taste the difference between grass fed and grain fed beef. The chicken, pork, turkey and fish are great too. And I love that they don’t use additional hormones or antibiotics.

  • The chicken is always tender and flavorful without lots of water. And they come well trimmed which saves me time.
  • The steaks are what I really love about ButcherBox. There’s a difference in taste between grass fed and grain fed meat.
  • Their heritage-breed pork has a nice marbling and great flavor. It’s much better than any pork I’ve bought at the supermarket.
  • The fish is always delivered fresh and moist without any fishy smell.
  • I really like the ground beef. It has a great taste just like their steaks.

Packaging

I really like how ButcherBox packages their meat. Each cut is individually freeze dried and bagged without those Styrofoam trays they use at the supermarket. This saves space in my small freezer which I really appreciate.

Since the meat deliveries are large it’s nice that they package things as tight as possible. This saves space in the freezer.

The box they ship the meat in is recyclable and the other packing materials are either biodegradable or recyclable. But the meat is shrink wrapped in plastic just like at my local grocery store or butcher.

butcher box on a counter

You Can Cancel Anytime

One of the best things about ButcherBox is how flexible they are. You can cancel at any time because there are no long term contracts like with many subscription services. And there are no penalties or fees for canceling.

You can also pause the deliveries at any time. I use this feature a lot because I travel and don’t need a delivery for months out of the year.

Another thing you can do is change the delivery address at any time.

ButcherBox is really easy to deal with and very flexible. I get a custom box so I’m always trying new things and adjusting my order. And I pause for weeks at a time when I’m traveling. As soon as I get home my deliveries resume at the click of a button.

ButcherBox Is A Good Deal

I’ve compared ButcherBox meats to meat I buy at my supermarket, butcher and other meat deliver services and think ButcherBox is definitely a good deal. There are definitely cheaper places to buy meat like Walmart and Costco, but the quality isn’t as good and you can’t beat the convenience.

Considering the quality of the meat ButcherBox delivers, the price is worth it.

ButcherBox comes out to around $5 bucks per meal. For the same quality humanely raised, grass-fed, organic, hormone & antibiotic free meat, the price is good. Especially when you consider they deliver the food right to your door and shipping is free.

When I do y comparison shopping I also consider the hour it saves me at the grocery store and the gas. With gas around $6 a gallon where I live ButcherBox works out to a really good deal.

Is ButcherBox Organic?

Butcher Box is a meat delivery service that delivers grass-fed beef, free-range organic chicken, heritage breed pork, turkey, fish and ground beef right to your doorstep. The meat is free of added hormones and antibiotics. So yes, ButcherBox is considered organic meat.

Butcher box sources all of their meat from sustainable farm in the US, Australia, and Canada. The meat is very high quality, tender and flavorful. It’s delivered frozen so the meat is always fresh.

Is ButcherBox Humane?

ButcherBox’s cattle are humanely raised, 100% grass-fed, and free of added hormones and antibiotics. The animals are free to roam on grassy pastures for their entire lives.

Most people consider free-grazing grass fed cattle to be a more humane way to raise and farm animals than grain fed.

Is ButcherBox Grass Fed?

ButcherBox Beef is 100% grass-fed and grass-finished. The cattle are free to graze on grassy pastures throughout their entire lives. The cows suckle from their mothers for the first 6-9 months and then eat a natural diet of grass.

Most people consider free-grazing grass fed cattle to be not only a more humane way to raise and farm animals but also much healthier.

Is ButcherBox A Subscription?

ButcherBox is a subscription meat delivery service. As a member you can choose from a variety of meats to fill either a predetermined meat box or a custom box where you select all the meat yourself.

Membership allows you to set up an order and delivery schedule which you can change at any time prior to billing.

Deliveries can be delayed or stopped at any time before your next order is billed without any hidden fees or penalties. You can also easily change your box type and delivery frequency prior to billing.

Is ButcherBox Cheaper Than Costco?

ButcherBox is more expensive than the meat you can buy at Costco. However, you need to compare equal quality meat.

When you compare grass-fed, hormone and antibiotic free meat at both ButcherBox and Costco, Costco is still a little cheaper. However, ButcherBox delivers the meat right to your door. And delivery is free.

If you have a local Costco and a membership, the meat is definitely cheaper. I don’t know about your Costco, but mine is packed with people every weekend which is the only time I can go. It’s hard to beat the convenience of getting meat delivered fresh right to my door.

Meat delivery services aren’t the best option for everyone, but for some it’s definitely cheaper.

In terms of quality they’re about the same. I really like the meat ButcherBox sends me but I also really like Costco.

Is ButcherBox Meat Frozen?

ButcherBox meat is frozen and shipped in an insulated carton on dry ice. This keeps the meat as fresh as possible.

Summary: Is ButcherBox Worth It?

A meat delivery service like ButcherBox that delivers 100% grass-fed beef, heritage breed pork, free range organic chicken and fish directly to your door is one of the best ways to get high-quality meat at a good price. Even before the pandemic I used meat delivery services because I regularly eat meat but don’t have time to go to the local butcher or supermarket. I try to eat healthy and like high-quality grass fed meat and organic chicken. Butcherbox meat doesn’t contain antibiotics or hormonesand the animals are treated humanely.

Meat boxes are totally customizable including ground beef and turkey. All the meat I’ve received has been great quality, it’s always arrived on time and at a good price. Based on the quality, customization and price, ButcherBox is definitely worth it and a good deal.

The meat boxes from ButcherBox are customizable. You can set up your deliveries on a set time-frame every 2 weeks or per month. The flexibility is a great feature because what I need changes from month to month.

I’ve tried several meat delivery services and am always very happy with ButcherBox.

If you have any questions about ButcherBox, email any time.

Related Posts

SUBSCRIBE

Get Notified About New Articles, GREAT DEALS on Home Goods, Videos & Product Reviews.

We Update Weekly & It’s All Completely FREE.